Showing posts with label mod. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mod. Show all posts

Friday, 9 September 2011

An easy swirly mod with extras

Yesterday I blogged about some of my attempts to get the Petzval swirl effect using home-made lenses in all formats from 4/3, 135 (35mm) to larger formats. The swirl effect is certainly possible with care in all formats, though generally speaking works better on larger formats. The lens-build is a bit involved, and needs some fiddling with sizes to get it right. It occurred to me when writing it that there might be an easier mod that anyone can do to get a lens to swirl on a DSLR or 35mm SLR. So I tried it, and it works. And, to my surprise there a pleasant "extra" waiting for anyone that has a go.

I've not seen this mod anywhere else, so if you mention it to anyone do say you found it here.

Modifying a standard lens

For this mod you need a camera (a 35mm SLR or a DSLR) that takes old fashioned 35mm SLR lenses. Most DSLRs have adapters to do this, or you can use a 35mm SLR. As far as I can see any sensible focal length should work, though some may be more useful than others. I used a 50mm lens on an Olympus 4/3 DSLR. This would be good for portaits and close-up details. It is quite important that the lens has some "depth" i.e. is reasonably long and complicated. A simple meniscus lens may not work.

The idea is, just as in the previous blog to add apertures at the front and rear. They don't have to be the same size, but they do have to be circular and central. I cut out some stiff black paper and glued it on the rear. The hole is about 5mm in diameter. Warning: you don't want paper fouling up your mirror, film or CCD sensor! Make sure the rear one is very firmly in place and it doesn't foul the focusing mechanism of the lens. You'll have to cut it very carefully.

50mm M42 standard lens with new aperture at rear

The one on the front was a good fit so it stays on by itself without any glue. This hole is about 16mm in diameter.

50mm M42 standard lens with new aperture at front

To cut paper, I use a Stanley knife. Then I sand it down with emery paper. Sorry, these are old-fashioned English terms for the tools in question, but I don't know the words in other languages.

The sizes (diameters of the holes) are quite critical and depend on your lens, in particular how long it is, its focal length, and what format you are shooting. I was shooting 4/3 with an image size about 1/2 that of a 35mm negative. For 35mm or "full frame" you might double my sizes. If you get vignetting your holes are too small. If you don't get vignetting they are too large. You want it so that you only just don't get vignetting, or you only get a little. That's for both holes.

Testing it

That's it! Now for the testing. As I said before, this "new" lens will behave just like a normal one most of the time, except that the aperture control won't have much effect except when it is very small. You need the right conditions, in particular to open up wide, focus close and have interesting background. When I tried it it worked straight away.

Evening sun in the woods

Don't look at the flare for a moment - look at the corners, and see how they swirl?

But the flare is a feature of this mod and I wasn't expecting it, but like it a lot. (I don't mean the orange and purple patch - that is due to the glass I was using and I'd seen that before. I mean the obvious white flary thing.) I have seen flares like this before - on roughly cut home-made pinhole cameras. The rough edge of the paper is making the flare. I don't fully understand how it works, and especially don't understand why colours appear. It's something to do with the rough edges behaving like a diffraction grating. But does it matter? Go out and enjoy it!

Finally

For the purists, this isn't the true Petzval swirl. These lenses are too good. For the real thing you need to add astigmatism or aberrations. I am not sure how to do that in the context of this "easy" mod. If you have any ideas do let me know.

Thursday, 8 September 2011

The Petzval swirlies

A certain kind of lens (called "Petzval Lenses") are very much in vogue because of the swirly effects they produce. You'll have to make up your mind what you think, but when used tastefully and subtly I rather like the effect .

Here's a Flickr gallery I made of some images with the Petzval swirl, and a few that claimed to have swirl but which are definitely not the real thing: http://www.flickr.com/photos/richard314159/galleries/72157624453174055/.

Does your camera swirl?

Obviously the first thing is to try it and see. You may be surprised. I was when I took a Tokina wide angle lens out a few months ago. This was a lens I had had for years and years, quite liked, but thought I knew it very well, what it could and couldn't do. But I just took some close-up shots of blossom and didn't think anything of it until I had scanned the negatives. I didn't see anything special in the (TTL) viewfinder when I took the shot, but to my astonishment when I looked at the scans, I got lots of swirl:

Frothy

You need to know what sort of conditions to try, to get the swirlies. When your eye is "in" it gets a bit easier, but to start with make it easy for yourself. You need to focus on something close - so twist the focus right out and get in close to something interesting. You need to have lots of interesting background all out of focus. And you want that background to have lots of tiny points of bright light. Go into the woods on a sunny day, take someone to photograph, or photograph the leaves and branches but always keep an eye on the background for the light coming in between the leaves. To make the background really out of focus open the lens right out to its fastest aperture.

Home-made swirly lenses

So maybe your lens doesn't swirl. You may have noticed that the best swirlies come from very big large format cameras with these old Petzval lenses. (This is, I think true.) What do you do? Buy such a camera and lens?

Well maybe. But it will cost you a lot, and not just money: these cameras are expensive and complicated to use, and the really good swirly lenses are pricey too, and you must have the right lens for the right camera. (With a swirly lens on a camera that's too small you just don't see the swirl.) All this means there's a lot to learn.

Lot of people say Petzval swirl is impossible on small cameras such as 35mm SLRs and DSLRs. I beg to differ. I have done it. But it is harder.

Why does it swirl?

The popular opinion is that a lens fault called astigmatism causes swirls. This may be true. Petzval lenses do have astigmatism. In fact it is certainly true, to some extent: astigmatism does make a lens swirl under certain conditions, but it is not the only reason, and possibly not the main reason.

My theory is that, in most cases, the lens swirls because it has the shape of a long barrel and the swirls are caused by the circular aperture at one end mismatching the circular aperture at the other end. Petzval lenses always had a slot for an aperture in the middle to avoid this problem. (And it's only the crazy people that want the swirls that leave this out.) Other effects like spherical aberration and astigmatism then might help more and make the swirls more pronnounced or change them slightly.

This means to make a lens that swirls you need to make it in a long barrel. Also make the barrel just the right length and the diameter just right too.

The geometry of a long barrel can be simulated by a long tube with two apertures at each end. I made apertures by cutting black card into circles and cutting holes in them. (Be careful: they have to be exactly circular and central.) Otherwise the lens is just like the one I talked about before on this blog. You just need two (roughly equal) close-up filters at the ends of the tube, with an aperture on each.

Here are some examples.

Olympus E-420 with homemade  Petzval-style lens Praktica MTL5B with homemade  Petzval-style lens Home-made Petzval-style lens

They all work. But it is not easy to get these lenses right. As I said, the holes at each end have to be just the right size. Too small and you only see a circular image, too big and you miss the swirls. The focal length of the glass and the length of the tube is important too. Keep experimenting and you'll get there.

This was done with a home-made lens on a 35mm SLR. I got my 4/3 DSLR to swirl too.

Blackthorn

Sunday, 21 August 2011

Slit scans on 35mm film

A while ago I wrote about multiple exposures and particularly about multiple exposure while winding film and panning or moving the camera. I promised I would explain the principle of the slitscan and how this evolves from the multiple exposure device. You may want to read the previous post at http://cameramods.blogspot.com/2011/07/from-multiple-exposures-to-slitscans.html before going any further with this one.

To start with, take a camera which can take very long narrow images. The way I do this is I glue cardboard or metal directly onto the focal plane, just in front of the film, to stop light getting to any part of the film except the thin slit in question. A picture of a modified camera was on the previous post where it was pointed out that simple inexpensive point-and-click 120 film cameras are ideal.

With some practice, pointing the camera and winding on the film at coordinated rates, such a camera can produce pictures that are rather representational, because the panning and the winding on are both about the same amount.

Emma

A slitscan camera

If it wasn't for those nasty hard lines and rather clunky appearance this is almost a normal picture taken in a different way. Well how do we get rid on the lines? The idea is to arrange that the "slit" gets narrower and narrower until it is only a few pixels or so wide and the film is wound on smoothly past the slit by some mechanism. This is actually not too difficult to arrange. Here is a normal 35mm camera with a slit added

Petri TTL with focal plane slit 1

The process is likened to a flatbed computer scanner: this can only "see" a thin line at a time but with the line moving it can actually put together quite complex images. In fact flatbed scanners have been converted to slitscan cameras too, but not by me. Not yet at least.

My preferred material to build these slits is the metal from an aluminium drinks can. This can actually be cut quite accurately with a sharp knife and steel rule. The technique is to cut the metal to size and then cut it in half, and it's important to ensure that you don't swap or turn over either piece after it's cut - any imperfections in the cut on one side should match the other side. The width of the slit should be as small as possible and very even - don't allow the slit to be wider at one end that the other as this will give different exposures and sharpness. A with of below 1mm is ideal. I estimated mine were about 0.2mm.

The next things to arrange are the shutter, which must be held open, and some mechanism to wind the film past the slit. For my early attempts I wound the film by hand using a home-made rewind crank of very exaggerated size.

Modified Petri TTL

This works pretty well. The main disadvantage is the camera must be on a tripod. But there is something quite satisfying about winding and panning the camera with one smooth motion both about the same speed. Since most cameras have nasty wind-on locks and double exposure prevention devices, the technique I used was to shoot the whole film blank with a lens cap on the lens, then somehow arrange the shutter to be open (on B perhaps) with the rewind button pressed, and rewind and pan the camera simultaneously. Some photographs taken this way are almost normal.

Gothic

As an alternative to panning the camera, you can arrange the camera is still and the subject moves. That's how these two cars were shot.

Two cars

The same principle is used commercially for cameras that take photographs of horses, greyhounds etc as they pass the winning post. Notice that as the camera is fixed the background is blurred in a characteristic "horizontal" way as the camera only sees a very thin slice of background repeated.

A combination of panning and taking pictures of moving objects can give surprising results. For example, one of the cars was moving here, making it appear much shorter than the car behind. In fact you can see both the front and rear of the car behind, with the car infront only covering the middle.

Relativity

You'll find plenty of other very wacky photographs of this type on the web.

Conclusions and further developments

There are some problems with this method.

The exposure is governed by: the speed of the film as it goes past the slit and the width of the slit. It is quite easy to calculate that if the speed of the film is V mm-per-second and the width of the slit is W mm then the effective exposure is W/V seconds. For this to be something "sensible" like 1/100 the slit needs to be very narrow.

The slit should be narrow for another reason: the narrower it is the sharper the images will be. Sometimes the panning and the speed of film match exactly, and the images are unexpectedly sharp, but more often one gets slightly blurry images which may be good enough or not, depending on what you want.

I find it is difficult to cut any slit completely evenly, which accounts for the horizontal lines seen in many of my pictures. It is also difficult to wind film evenly, and unevenness in this accounts for vertical lines.

The slit does introduce the chance for the film to get scratched. In fact this is a minimal problem compared to the others, but it is a problem.

Finally, as I have described it, these cameras need a tripod.

On the other hand, these cameras have the advantage that the pictures they take are not limited to the width of a normal frame on 35mm film, but can be as long as you want. Panoramic photographs are very much possible.

I future posts I will give some other ideas that simplify the process and make the cameras easier to use. This involves perhaps using a motor to wind the film. There are also ways to simulate slitscans with a digital camera that can take video. You may also find that your camera's focal plane shutter already behaves as a slitscanner, or that your digital camera (especially phone camera) works so slowly it too behaves as a slit scan. Watch this space!

Thursday, 21 July 2011

Yesterday's photo

Here's the photo I took yesterday.

Garden study

There are lots of things wrong, most notably a light leak that comes as a big white splodge on the right. But I was happy with this: because there's no similar splodge on the left. That means the film holder I made works on one side. When I worked out which side is good, which bad (remembering that the image on film is upside down) I could see that one side is slightly better than the other. So all I have to do is fix up the other side too, and that does not seem so difficult now I know that all I have to do is make it like the other one.

Experimental design

There's another tip here. Every experiment should if possible test only one thing. Then you know if it didn't work what was wrong. I'd already tested the film and the developer I was using in another camera and knew that was fine. So that eliminates one possible source of problems. And so on. It's sometimes tempting to rush ahead and try lots of new things all at once, but it doesn't always pay in the long run.

There's something else strange about this photo, but not really so strange because I'd seen it before somewhere else and was half-expecting it. That's the big sideways-on moon-shaped curve at the top. This is because the lens I was using didn't "cover" the huge negative. This is a common problem with large cameras and easily identified. In fact some photographers made it almost a trade-mark, and used such vignetting due to lack of lens-coverage as a feature of their pictures. Eugène Atget was one such photographer.

In my case, I'd rather have this vignette when I choose to have it, and not leave it to chance. That means I will have to modify something to get rid of it, possibly introducing it again when I really want it. But I was surprised it was so noticeable - I was expecting the lens to very nearly cover the negative. When I had put this lens together I had calculated what to expect, and it wasn't supposed to be this bad. I checked my calculations, they were OK. Eventually I decided to check the +1 close-up lens I was using.

The focal length of a lens

A good quick way to estimate the focal length of a lens is to project an image of the sun (which is effectively "at infinity") onto board or paper and measure the lens-to-image distance. (I will have to say more about this later too.) In my case it was about 650mm, and the lens was supposed to be +1 dioptre or 1000mm. That's appalling - very inaccurate. Soon I will be measuring the focal length of some of my other lenses to see if they measure up to what the manufacturer says.

When I redid the calculations with 650mm they came out in line with what I had observed. Again this is bad news in a way, but good in that one more variable has been eliminated. And so it will go on.

Scratches

To finish today, here is a detail from that 20x24 image.

Detail

Close-up you see a nice feature - lots of little scratches on the film. This really is an interesting film-hack to know about. There are some wonderful effects with scratched film that would take a photoshopper a month of Sundays to make. (Or do you buy things in photoshop?;) But again, I don't want them all the time so I will have to investigate. There's a clue - all the scratches are parallel. That means I think that they were made when the whole film slid as one piece either cutting or mounting the film in the holder. Another thing to investigate.